Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Public clam digging continues in many coastal wetlands also managed for conservation, so managers need evidence on whether small, low-cost access restrictions retain harvestable stock. At 16 paired stations in Siangshan Wetland, Taiwan, we compared the clam Cyclina sinensis (Gmelin, 1791) between plots open to public digging (U) and 6-m 2 closures marked with rope and signs. One closure per station (C1) was excavated after four to five months and again six months later; a second (C2) was excavated once, after 11 months. The primary endpoint was shell-on wet biomass of clams > 30 mm, the approximate size kept by collectors. Closures held about three times this biomass on both dates (model-estimated ratios 3.25–3.55; all lower 95% limits ≥ 1.60). Total density was 2.0–2.9 times higher, whereas the proportion > 30 mm did not differ detectably, indicating that closures held more clams rather than a larger share of large clams. Six months after its first excavation, C1 again held 69 clams > 30 mm, more than the 60 removed, an observation relevant to rotational closures. Power simulations showed that 16 paired stations give 86% power to detect a threefold difference but 42% for a twofold difference; 80% power for the latter would need more than 32 stations. Because closure positions were fixed, nonrandom and not sampled before installation, initial stock differences remain an alternative explanation, and the data do not separate retention, growth and immigration. Baseline-matched, randomized trials with marked clams are the next step in evaluating small closures as a wetland management tool.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Chang et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: