Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Annual Allowable Cut (AAC) is the maximum volume of timber permitted to be harvested annually under an approved forest management plan, expressed in cubic metres per year, and is a critical component of sustainable forestry. In Bhutan, commercial timber harvesting is regulated through FMUs operating under successive ten-year management plans. This study compared actual timber extraction with prescribed AAC volumes across 20 FMUs and examined differences between management periods. AAC utilisation (the percentage of prescribed timber volume extracted) under current management plans varied markedly among FMUs (mean = 88%, median = 64%, range = 0.8%–475%). Six of the 20 FMUs were ahead of the time-adjusted AAC benchmark (the cumulative AAC for the operational years elapsed; only two had formally exceeded their full ten-year AAC), while ten recorded utilisations below 70% of the AAC. Among the 16 FMUs with data available for both management periods, there was no clear statistical evidence for a difference in AAC utilisation between previous and current plans (Wilcoxon signed-rank test, W = 47.0, p = 0.298). Conifer FMUs had greater standing volume, basal area, and AAC utilisation than broadleaved FMUs. Exploratory regression suggested an association between forest types and AAC utilisation; however, the overall model lacked statistical support, and the association was sensitive to individual FMUs. Overall, the results indicate that timber harvesting across Bhutan’s FMU network is characterised by substantial variation in AAC implementation rather than systematic overharvesting. Timber extraction fell below 70% of the time-adjusted prescribed AAC in half of the FMUs, indicating widespread underharvesting relative to planned volumes. These findings provide a quantitative assessment of actual timber extraction relative to prescribed AAC across Bhutan’s FMUs and highlight the need to examine constraints on achieving planned harvest levels. The study does not assess regeneration, biodiversity, soil impacts, or changes in growing stock, so AAC utilisation alone should not be read as evidence of ecological sustainability.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tshering et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: