Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Pre-registration of a sealed comparison, deposited before any image of the lot was opened. Methods compared: a rule-based lesion border tracer (frozen version, identified below by hash only) against a U-Net and Segment Anything (box prompt and point prompt), each compared with the rule one by one. Images: 2,000 dermoscopic images from the ISIC archive with expert outlines (IMA++, skill level S1), drawn by lot (grouped by patient, seed 20261115) from images never used in any earlier step; the images used to train the U-Net were also excluded. The list of image identifiers is sealed. Primary outcome: mean Dice over all images of the lot, excluding images whose reference outline touches the end of the illuminated field (2% margin), by a criterion written before opening and applied to all methods alike. Paired difference per image, 95% bootstrap CI (2,000 resamples, seed 20261200), margin 0.023. Sealed before opening (SHA-256):- seal covering all files below: 6d8395ef4d833ddeaf96bded45c5d7d09ae724562d7510c27e118b4305715ba0- rule, frozen version (entry file): 27fdd5ebfbdf6a7ffead18b843ee6fb3aa6e85144774a2dc004b015d4ec4de63- criterion of this comparison: c86216fe88d16073444f85910bab27f8d31714f3c54a9b9aed63efb195780d6d- criterion for the networks, one by one: c05709a361d854f5e9b143c9f5c5fec865fcec1a832495e1316035a0e53afba8- frame rule: 027c12ca3ba2563a169e67d3ee103beb4617f261aa6505dd220c4d7fecdc13d6- list of images: 27b3a244da7bd6d8a1835e1e96e70f83af547847a98c0845926935325bc84f2d- prediction of the author: 15713724ed710d6376267db75781d7c6ad55b3d8722fa4ab3dcc21f5b70f5b0e- predictions of the two AI assistants: 7bbcd96e14ffc6c122b3a329ba7c9c39429947abf40fc410d41a59fd75fb4109 and 132c152c08f57502b00601424d081db6cbd9bc4447652148bad848ec53f1aca5- full list of hashes (uploaded file): 9df38156b7aadc2f6ff5ec44a4eb58b8f2b63959eeaa64298e35053bc4de2174 Files are restricted. The rule itself is not deposited. The script that runs the lot will be added as a new version, by hash, before any image of the lot is downloaded. The results will be deposited as a new version, with the same hashes. Criterion and predictions written in Portuguese. AI assistants were used under the author's direction and are named in the criterion.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Fabio da Camara Oliveira Ferreira (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: