Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background. Earlier studies have linked parents' divorce, childhood abuse and neglect, and parenting in adolescence with adult couple relationships; for childhood material disadvantage the evidence on couple outcomes is less direct. Whether such links hold across cohorts, and whether they remain once the adult's own personality and stress are taken into account, matters for models of couple risk. Methods. A preregistered secondary analysis (https://osf.io/tne52) of three US cohorts: Add Health (5,114 public-use Wave IV respondents, of whom 3,713 were followed to Wave V in 2016–18), the Health and Retirement Study (HRS; 14,758 respondents to the 2006 or 2008 psychosocial questionnaire, including 4,277 couples analysed for dissolution through 2022) and the NLSY79 Children and Young Adults (CYA; 3,620 ever-married young adults of 2,296 mothers analysed). Twenty-one registered tests in ten families related four childhood circumstances to relationship quality, violence between partners and separation or divorce. P-values were Holm-corrected within families; a 95% interval within ±0.10 SD or ±5 percentage points counted as evidence of no meaningful association. Results. Fourteen of the 21 tests were supported. Each kind of maltreatment (of three) was associated with lower relationship quality (−0.15 SD) and more violence toward (+6.1 percentage points) and from (+8.4) the partner at the same interview, and predicted lower happiness and more violence seven to ten years later. Each SD of closeness to parents in adolescence predicted higher relationship quality and less violence at Wave IV, and less marital dissolution (−3.8 points; N = 1,523), although the dissolution result was not significant without survey weights or with the other childhood circumstances in the model. A mother living without a spouse during childhood predicted +11.0 points of separation or divorce (CYA); the Add Health test based on the parent's report was inconclusive (+4.6, 95% CI −1.4 to 10.5). Material disadvantage predicted dissolution in Add Health (+3.2 points per SD), a result that held without weights and in a logistic model but not in the sample of the earlier papers, next to the other childhood predictors or after adult measures; the HRS test could not be estimated. In HRS, adversity was associated with more spouse strain (+0.13 SD) but not with couple dissolution beyond the bound. After adding adult neuroticism, anger and stress, 11 of 12 supported Add Health associations remained, reduced by 13% to 54%; the HRS strain association did not (−78%). Conclusions. In these three US cohorts, closeness to parents reported in adolescence and maltreatment recalled in adulthood were markers of adult relationship problems; in Add Health, adult personality and stress captured them only in part, while in older HRS couples the link of adversity with spouse strain did not remain. Evidence for parental separation and material disadvantage was less consistent. The results are associations, not evidence of cause.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Mateo Jurin (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: