Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Purpose This study aims to compare the efficiency of electronic bills of lading with that of paper-based bills of lading. It focuses on their ability to prove the contract of carriage of goods by sea, demonstrate receipt of the goods transported and facilitate the transfer of ownership between traders. Design/methodology/approach The study will adopt a qualitative approach which is based on theoretical critical analysis and uses a black letter approach whereby a descriptive-analytical approach will be applied. Thus, it will examine UAE Maritime Law 2023 and Electronic Transactions and Trust Services Law, to define the concept of electronic bills of lading and establish legal rules to ensure their effectiveness in fulfilling the functions outlined above. This will be conducted with a comparative analysis of the relevant international regulations and conventions. Findings There are inconsistencies and ambiguities in international documents regarding the timing of goods delivery specified in the bill of lading. Some instruments lack clarity on when the goods should be delivered, as the timing fluctuates between the date on the bill of lading and the date declared by the shipper. In addition, there is no regulation for delivering goods upon arrival in an electronic bill of lading, nor is there a mechanism to determine the timing of such delivery. While these instruments mandate the use of encrypted private keys to ensure the validity and smooth circulation of electronic bills of lading and require registration of ownership transfers in an electronic system, they do not explicitly address the bill of lading’s role as proof of ownership of the goods. In the UAE, while the law acknowledges the validity of electronic bills of lading and their three traditional functions, it provides only a general treatment of them. This lack of specific legal treatment creates ambiguity around their functions, affecting the determination of ownership transfer and the delivery time of goods. Originality/value There is currently no precise legal framework for electronic bills of lading, resulting in legal uncertainties, particularly in the UAE, where the process remains unregulated. The novelty of this study lies in the issue that no study has addressed this, in particular under the new UAE maritime law nor addressed the effect of this document on the legal implications of the contract of sale of goods.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Al-Daboubi et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: