Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Schools increasingly run programmes that prepare students for responsible internet behaviour, yet little is known about whether such programmes are associated with how adolescents evaluate their lives, or for whom. Drawing on the bioecological model and the differential susceptibility to media effects model, we examined associations between a school-level indicator of digital citizenship provision and adolescent life satisfaction in three independent cohorts of the Programme for International Student Assessment (2018, 2022 and 2025). School principals reported whether their school had a specific programme to prepare students for responsible internet behaviour. We used causal forests to estimate conditional associations with life satisfaction and to test whether these associations differed by socioeconomic status, home digital access, gender and immigrant background, and we tested whether the pattern found in 2018 appeared in the independent 2025 cohort. Students in schools with a programme did not report meaningfully higher life satisfaction than comparable students in schools without one, and the programme indicator was not associated with feeling pressured to be online or anxious without a device. In the primary analyses the association did not differ by the four student characteristics, and the 2018 ranking of students did not identify stronger associations in 2025. Analyses that took the survey design, country weighting, missing data and school-level differences into account led to the same overall conclusion, although conventional models that weighted countries equally showed small and inconsistent differences across student characteristics. The confidence intervals ruled out average associations larger than a few hundredths of a standard deviation. A principal's report that a programme exists tells us little about adolescent wellbeing; measures of programme content, implementation and students' experience are needed.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kovaç et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: