Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A central question in political psychology concerns the motivational roots of ideological differences between left and right. A common approach explains right-wing thinking as reflecting heightened sensitivity to threat and a motivation to protect the status quo. We argue that this approach rests on an incomplete model of goals, which overlooks the motive to conserve. Building on the ternary goal model, we examine whether the right is better characterized by maintenance (sustaining a valued present) than by protection (responding to threats). Using a multilingual classifier validated on human-rated statements, we measured goals in a top-down manner, in 892 party platforms from 11 countries, and bottom-up, in the goals spontaneously reported by 2,333 citizens in six countries and in citizens’ support for platform statements that differed in goal orientation. Top-down, right-wing parties were more maintenance-oriented than left-wing parties, and in recent decades less progress-oriented. Protection orientation did not differ by side but was higher in opposition and at the ideological margins. Bottom-up, citizens showed a similar pattern. Progress orientation was strongest on the left. Maintenance orientation followed a curve that peaked among moderate conservatives. Its linear rise with conservatism was suppressed by institutional trust, which was lower on the right. In support ratings, progress-oriented statements appealed more to the left and maintenance-oriented statements more to the right, whereas protection-oriented statements favored neither. The left–right divide thus sets two constructive aims – to progress and to maintain – against each other, while protection marks those in opposition and at the margins.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ecker et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: