Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Debates on diversity and citizenship in Europe have shifted from disagreements over the content of equal citizenship to doubts about whether certain groups – especially citizens with migration backgrounds and Muslims – can ever fully belong to the liberal-democratic community. This article argues that a framework of equal citizenship, understood as equality in democratic status, is better suited than multicultural citizenship to understand and contest these developments. Drawing on the Dutch context, it, first, argues that multiculturalism has become so politically discredited that it no longer provides an effective language through which to defend inclusion and equality. Second, it shows that contemporary anti-multiculturalism should not primarily be understood as a critique of multicultural policies, but rather as part of a broader populist and illiberal challenge to liberal-democratic constitutionalism itself. Third, it argues multiculturalism’s cultural vocabulary is relatively ill-equipped to confront contemporary forms of integrationism, culturalization, and nativism that currently construct hierarchies of citizenship. Fourth, the article argues that equal citizenship is not merely an alternative to multicultural citizenship but can also deepen and refine multicultural theory itself, particularly with regard to immigrant integration. Fifth, the article shows that an equal citizenship lens also sharpens critiques of recent theories of ‘majority rights,’ which wrongly presume that ethnocultural majorities are uniquely reliable carriers of liberal democracy, while casting minorities as distinctive threats to it. In an anti-multicultural era, insisting on equal citizenship is therefore the most precise and urgent way to defend democratic equality.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tamar de Waal (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: