Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In the octonionic approach to the Standard Model, electric charge is quantised because it is the eigenvalue of anumber operator. We ask whether the same algebra fixes mass ratios, with Koide's relation for the charged leptons asthe test, and we keep apart what is proved, what is assumed and what was only noticed in data. The square roots ofthe three masses of a charged sector are written as the roots of one 3×3 matrix with a centre, a spread (Koide'sratio K) and a phase. (1)~For such a matrix with octonionic entries, K depends only on the centre and the norms ofthe entries, and the phase only on their triple product, which for imaginary entries is the octonionic three-form ofthe three directions. (2)~With diagonal entry $1$ and off-diagonal entries of squared norm 12 the identitygives K=23; both numbers occur in our papers of 2021--22. This is not a derivation: othernormalisations the programme could equally use give 10/27, 512, 12, $1$,13/12 or 10/3, and the matrix so defined does not have the lepton masses as its roots. (3)~In that construction arotation of the electric charge shifts the Koide phase, so no charge-conserving rule can fix it. (4)~The leptonrelation holds for the physical masses and fails for running masses at the Z mass. In the same form, with latticeratios of quark masses, the down-type quarks have $K=0.83385(50)$ if their lightest root is negative, 1.0σabove 56 as the comparison was run and between 0.1σ below and 1.9σ above over the latticeaverages and the definitions of the masses that could have been used; the comparison was specified beforehand butwas not blind. The up-type quarks, with Yukawa couplings at the Z mass, have $K=0.8875(5)$, 2.8σ below89 as run and 1.5σ to 2.9σ below over the same choices. For the sequence23,56,89 as a whole the p-value is $0.03$ as run, and between $0.01$ and $0.2$ over thosechoices. (5)~The unconstrained stationary values available to a three-generation cycle can only be13, 12 and $1$; and the free quadratic action of the theory selects no ratio of its amplitudes, henceno mass ratio if the family matrices are linear in them. (6)~One completion is followed to the masses: the familymatrix at two Higgs vertices, with three heavy leptons. To leading order the lepton masses are then the squares ofits roots, but the completion fixes neither K nor the phase; and at tree level an exact K=23 for thematrix is a relation between running masses, lowered further by the mixing with the heavy leptons. (7)~A form of thedown-type matrix read off the data ties|Vcb|/|Vᵤₛ| to the down-type masses and gives |Vcb|=0.0419(2); it is recorded with its predictions andis not claimed as a result. (8)~Other constructions in which the two lepton numbers appear, among them one on theClifford algebra C₈, can be written in the same three-parameter form. In those whose argument for the ratiowe assess, the value 23 enters through an added condition which, in our reading, is not derived; and29 is read off the masses or is the value of an expression that is then identified with the phase. Wherethe two numbers are fixed at 23 and29, the physical masses exclude the pair at 10⁻⁵ in m_μ/mₑ. (9)~With the running of the StandardModel the Koide ratio of the leptons for running masses at a common scale is $0.66783$, the same to within10⁻⁵ at every scale from the Z mass to 10¹⁶~GeV, as is known in substance, so no choice of scalereconciles a relation for such masses withthe physical masses. Our picture of two four-dimensional spacetimes, with mass placed in ours and chargein the other, adds nothing to the known reading that Koide's relation is one between physical masses: what thatreading uses is ordinary physics in one spacetime, and the picture's own charge for mass, where our papers defineit through a running coupling, does not fit it. We propose that any relation the algebra may fix is one between physical masses. That reading issilent about the quark sectors; and neither with masses at a common scale, nor with physical lepton masses andquark masses as the data tables list them, do the three sectors have the three values of~(4). If the square rootsof the three lepton masses were charges of one compact $U(1)$ they would stand in whole-number ratios, which anexact Koide relation forbids. In the constructions examined the charges are fixed by the algebra and the massratios are not; in the rule of our earlier papers, which builds the masses from products of roots, they are byconstruction, and the data exclude that rule as an exact statement. The constructions examined do not select theobserved mass ratios. They identify the algebraic and physical conditions that are missing, and they do notexclude that a different construction of matter supplies them. The source package contains the inputs, the codebehind the numbers and the stored outputs.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tejinder P. Singh (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: