Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Reported earthquake stress drops vary by several orders of magnitude, and part of that spread may reflect methodological choices rather than differences in earthquake source properties. We estimate source parameters for 1303 ML 2.0–5.8 earthquakes in and around the southern Korean Peninsula using S-wave displacement spectra, an independently derived attenuation model, and three corner-frequency estimators. Revisiting the spectral formulation of Snoke (1987), we confirm that the low-frequency coefficient should be 2 rather than 41/4. This correction corresponds to a factor of 2 in seismic moment M0 for the full-band expression, although the resulting shift depends on the subsequent estimation procedure. For our bandlimited integral estimator, M0 increases by a median factor of 1.51 and corner frequency fc decreases by a median factor of 0.76. Even with the corrected coefficient, the three estimators yield different fc–M0 scaling slopes, with the largest differences observed for the Gyeongju and Pohang mainshocks. Nevertheless, event rankings based on M0, fc, and stress drop remain consistent across estimators. The Gyeongju sequence shows higher stress drops than the Pohang sequence across analysis choices that retain the reference attenuation correction. However, this difference becomes less pronounced under alternative attenuation models and is not statistically significant under one of them. Holding M0 and fc fixed, we find that alternative stress-drop relations and rupture models shift the absolute stress-drop estimates and the inferred radiation efficiencies enough to change their physical interpretation. Our results show that relative differences among events and earthquake sequences are more robust than absolute estimates and inferred scaling relationships. At the same time, the reliability of derived quantities remains dependent on the underlying parameter estimates and model assumptions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Son et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: