Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background Presence refers to a learner’s subjective sense of being within a simulated situation. Although presence may influence how learners engage with simulation, existing measures were developed primarily for virtual environments, and evidence supporting their use in manikin-based simulation is limited. We aimed to adapt an existing presence measure for use in manikin-based simulation and to assess whether it could be administered in routine simulation courses. Methods Twelve established presence and immersion questionnaires were identified through a targeted literature search; five were shortlisted and appraised against six predefined criteria by experts in a two-round structured review. The selected Igroup Presence Questionnaire was contextually adapted while retaining its 14-item format and proposed domain allocation. The adapted questionnaire was administered after an obstetric-emergencies course and a crisis resource management course. Responses were recorded on the original − 3 to + 3 scale, recoded to 0–6 for reporting, and summarized descriptively. Results The expert panel selected the Igroup Presence Questionnaire based on its length, reported measurement properties, availability of translations, and existing reference data. Most changes replaced terminology specific to virtual environments, although several items required more extensive rewording. Twenty of 34 course participants submitted questionnaire responses (58.8%): 9 of 18 in the obstetric-emergencies course and 11 of 16 in the crisis resource management course. Nineteen respondents answered all 14 items, while one omitted SP3. No spontaneous concerns about item wording were recorded, although clarity was not assessed formally. Spatial presence had the highest median score in both courses (obstetric emergencies: 3.40, IQR 3.05–3.75, n = 8; crisis resource management: 4.80, IQR 3.60–5.20, n = 11). No inferential between-course comparison was performed. Conclusions The adapted questionnaire could be administered in two manikin-based simulation courses. This pilot does not establish the validity or reliability of the adapted instrument or support comparisons between courses. Cognitive interviews with intended respondents and evaluation in a larger, multicenter sample are required before the scores can be used to evaluate simulation design.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Abramovich et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: