Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Hijri calendar determination in Indonesia spans a spectrum from traditional urfi (arithmetic) calculation to astronomy-based hakiki systems, and the divergence in month-beginnings recurs annually. The traditional Al-Karawi system of Sumenep, Madura, remains under-documented. This study reconstructs the Al-Karawi algorithm and quantifies its relationship to the three methods operative in Indonesia — the Ministry of Religious Affairs (Neo MABIMS), Muhammadiyah’s Wujud al-Hilal, and the Unified Global Hijri Calendar (KHGT), which Muhammadiyah adopted from 1447 H — across all twelve months of 1446–1460 H (180 month-beginnings per pair). Al-Karawi is confirmed as a pure urfi system whose distinctiveness rests on a single feature: leap-year placement at year 15 rather than year 16 of the 30-year cycle. It coincides with the Ministry on only 26.1% of months but with KHGT on 52.8%, so Muhammadiyah’s adoption of KHGT made its calendar Al-Karawi’s nearest institutional neighbour while widening its distance from the Ministry (73.9% to 56.7%). Divergence varies significantly by Hijri month (ANOVA p < 0.001) and is temporally stable. A three-parameter framework relocates the fault line from urfi-versus-hakiki to observational-versus-computational.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ridlalllah et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: