Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This study examines how North Korean youth who used smartphones before defecting negotiated privacy, autonomy, and everyday agency under device-embedded surveillance, termed here the ‘mobile panopticon’. It combines Giorgi’s descriptive phenomenology, applied to interviews with nine defectors, with an Actor-Network Theory (ANT) analysis of technical reports, legal texts, and participants’ accounts. The study reveals how circumvention of surveillance carved out private autonomy, de-monopolised cognitive horizons, and renegotiated biographical trajectories, held together by fear and transgressive pleasure. A heuristic three-phase periodisation – ‘open window’ (2008–2013), ‘walled garden’ (2014–2017), and ‘beyond the wall’ (2018 onward) – shows the state’s efforts at enclosure extending from device architecture into law, while users moved from ‘side gates’ and ‘breaches’ to media outside the handset. Integrating both layers, the study proposes ‘embodied sociotechnical agency’, comprising embodied interiority, sociotechnical buffering, and agency reconfiguration, and shows how circumvention became, for some participants, a condition of counter-conduct. The findings characterise this defector subgroup, not North Korean youth as a whole, and extend Scott’s ideas of hidden transcripts and Foucauldian counter-conduct to device-embedded surveillance.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
SungJoon Joung (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: