Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This is the fourth of five papers presenting Source Energy Field Theory (SEFT). Between an emergent metric and general relativity stand three structural requirements: that all excitations propagate on one causal cone, that the graviton have exactly two polarizations, and that the constraints close in the right algebra. This paper treats them as gates and reports what the construction currently passes. A sufficient common-principal-cone condition is the factorization PμνAB = ZAB gμν; the minimal two-field block satisfies it on the stated background. Cone existence, agreement with the collective metric, and absence of an independent clock residue are separate gates. The cone-matching test is strengthened to check the full mixed-tensor residual, since generalized eigenvalues alone miss a Lorentzian nilpotent counterexample. Schur elimination preserves a common scalar-pencilled dispersion exactly only when the full quadratic operator depends on frequency and wavenumber through one scalar invariant; first-derivative amplitude–phase mixing need not have this form and can change the low-energy phase speed already at tree level. For the spin-2 gate we state what fixes two polarizations and what the construction currently has; for the constraint-algebra gate we show that the relevant object is a rank rather than a norm. A positive gap suppresses heavy modes but does not by itself remove background-dependent Wilson coefficients; the matching conditions are also required. The remaining gravitational task is a Dirac constraint analysis from a candidate collective Hamiltonian to a rank, which is necessary but not sufficient. Several routes are recorded as withdrawn, among them the identification of node-permutation invariance as the discrete origin of local diffeomorphism invariance. Claims are marked [D], [C], [H] or [X] within their stated model. Section numbering is continuous across Papers I–V. AI contribution: Large language models were used for connecting the construction to established physics and for symbolic and numerical verification. They did not originate the theory, and their agreement with a claim was not treated as evidence for it. All claims and any remaining errors are the authors' responsibility.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sakihara et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: