Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Urban trees must maintain ecosystem services under interacting heat, hydrological, edaphic, pollution, and management stresses, yet species comparisons often combine heterogeneous forms of evidence. Ginkgo biloba L. is a Chinese-endemic relict tree now cultivated worldwide; despite its widespread urban use, its net role in urban ecosystems and the limits of its resilience remain incompletely resolved. We conducted a structured critical review comparing G. biloba with five reference taxa ( Platanus × acerifolia , Tilia cordata , Acer platanoides , Betula pendula , and Quercus robur ) across air pollution, de-icing salt exposure, drought, soil compaction and pavement effects, heat, biotic stress, and mechanical injury. A supplementary study-level evidence map documents 62 empirical or model-based publications used to support, qualify, or delimit the principal comparative and mechanistic claims. Primary findings are distinguished from contextual and methodological literature, and the original literature assembly, source verification and a separately documented supplementary revision search are reported independently. Evidence was interpreted according to study design, directness, urban realism, comparator availability, and outcome relevance; heterogeneity precluded meta-analysis. The literature indicates context-dependent performance, rather than universal superiority of G. biloba . Field and controlled studies suggest stable water relations in some dry or paved settings and tolerance of moderate or episodic salt exposure, but direct interspecific evidence remains limited. Particulate-matter retention is inconsistent across studies, and low or negligible isoprene emission under the conditions studied does not imply zero emission or general atmospheric superiority. Severe drought, excess atmospheric humidity, prolonged or chemically aggressive de-icer exposure, poor establishment, and transplant stress can reduce performance. Species selection should therefore be site-specific, and the proposed resilience framework should be treated as a testable synthesis rather than an experimentally validated ranking.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Orlóci et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: