Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The preservation of historic masonry structures remains a major challenge due to the complexity of their structural behaviour and the progressive loss of traditional construction knowledge. In this context, limit analysis, as developed by Jacques Heyman, provides a particularly effective equilibrium-based framework for assessing masonry stability, since equilibrium and geometry play a more significant role than material strength. In September 2017, the dome of the Church of Nuestra Señora de los Ángeles (NSA) in Mexico City partially collapsed following a major earthquake. Prior to the seismic event, the dome had already developed meridional cracking and geometric deformations caused by long-term differential settlements and the unusually heavy original stone lantern. The earthquake triggered a precarious kinematic condition that culminated in the partial collapse of the dome five days later. This paper investigates the structural causes and the collapse mechanism through a series of equilibrium-based approaches interpreted within Heyman’s rigid no-tension framework. Thrust-line analysis using the slicing technique, pseudo-static tilting analysis, and kinematic limit analysis are employed to evaluate the collapse multiplier, identify the governing collapse mechanism, and assess the geometric safety conditions of the structure. Particular attention is devoted to the influence of the lantern weight on the equilibrium of the hemispherical dome and on the stability of the supporting drum. The analyses indicate that the original stone lantern represented one of the principal sources of structural vulnerability for the specific geometry of the NSA dome. They further show that a substantial reduction in the lantern weight significantly improves the geometric safety conditions of the dome, thereby making it possible to reconstruct the collapsed portion using traditional masonry techniques. The analyses were supported by a set of multi-temporal laser-scanning and photogrammetric surveys acquired before and after the collapse and during the reconstruction process, providing a unique geometric dataset for documenting deformations, crack patterns, their evolution, and the changing equilibrium conditions of the dome.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Barrera et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: