Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Purpose This paper reviews the literature on impression management (IM) in corporate disclosures and systematically compares research on financial disclosures (FD) and non-financial disclosures (NFD), particularly sustainability reporting. Given the maturity of IM research in FD and the recent acceleration of IM research in NFD driven by societal and regulatory pressures, the study aims to identify commonalities, differences, and research gaps between both streams, and to assess how insights from FD research can inform future IM research in NFD. Design/methodology/approach We conduct a structured review of 83 archival studies published since 2000 in leading accounting and sustainability journals. The review compares FD and NFD studies along key dimensions, including motivators of IM, disclosure instruments, sample characteristics, and econometric approaches, thereby enabling a systematic assessment of methodological and conceptual differences between the two research streams. Findings The review yields four main findings. First, theoretical frameworks in NFD research remain largely disconnected from capital-market considerations that anchor FD research. Second, NFD research focuses predominantly on sustainability performance as a motivator of IM, leaving other motivators – such as CSR contracting, investor sustainability preferences, and political influence – largely unexplored. Third, prior studies emphasize textual IM instruments, while visual and structural elements central to sustainability reporting remain underexamined. Fourth, NFD studies typically rely on smaller samples and less rigorous econometric designs than FD research, limiting robustness and replicability. Originality/value This study systematically compares archival IM research across FD and NFD. By synthesizing insights from the mature FD literature, it develops a research agenda that broadens the scope of IM motivators, advances the measurement of visual and structural disclosure practices, and strengthens methodological rigor in future NFD research.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Müller et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: