Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In many practical multiphase flows, there exists a high density ratio between liquid and gas phases. Since the flow properties are discontinuous at the interface between the fluid phases, accurate simulations of such flows are challenging due to the propensity for inconsistent treatment of mass and momentum transport in the calculation of the non-linear convective term in the momentum equation. This study compares six mass–momentum transport schemes across three flow solvers—three from Basilisk, two from two development lines of OpenFOAM, and one from an in-house solver—that employ the Volume-of-Fluid method to track volume. The consistency and accuracy of the schemes are assessed with two test cases: convective translation of a highly dense drop, and collapse of a water column in air. The comparison of results among the solvers shows that without tight coupling between mass and momentum transport, purely convective flows with large density contrast are highly susceptible to numerical errors that are manifested as non-physical deformations on the interface separating liquid and gas phases. Such non-physical deformations persist even with mesh refinement. However, if diffusion and/or any other linear forces are present in flows with large density contrast, they can mask the inaccuracy that might be present in the scheme for mass and momentum transport.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sharma et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: