Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This document is one of the final deliverables of the CO-SUSTAIN project. It compares the implementation and results of the six deliberation processes run in the six case studies of civic and political participation between November 2025 and June 2026: the regeneration of public space in Annelinn (Tartu, Estonia), resident participation in large-scale energy projects, starting from small modular reactors (Espoo, Finland), the activist campaign for the Westbahnareal (Vienna, Austria), the food solidarity system of Turin (Italy), an inclusive shared-energy network in El Raval (Barcelona, Spain) and an energy community in the Alpujarra (Órgiva, Spain). In doing so, it returns to the question formulated at the start of the project: under which conditions, and through which factors and dynamics, does participation produce which effects on democratic pathways to transition? In simpler terms: what happens, where, why, and with what results? The comparison builds on the CO-SUSTAIN theoretical triangle: sustainability transition theory (the multi-level perspective, MLP, read together with social movement theory following Törnberg), political and civic participation (Ekman and Amnå’s typology of latent and manifest participation and Tilly’s theory of collective action) and participatory, deliberative and prefigurative democracy. It adopts a generalising approach, complementary to the case-specific Impact Assessment Framework of Task 4.1, and a context–mechanism–outcome (CMO) logic inspired by realist evaluation. The comparison is organised in three stages. Stage 1 compares the contexts in two steps: an MLP reading of the causal loop diagrams (CLDs) produced in the panels, which identifies the loops that stabilise the regime, those that challenge it, the dynamics within the niches and the connections across levels; and the partners’ answers on collective action mobilisation, windows of opportunity, niche–regimeinteraction and transition pathways. Stage 2 compares the deliberation processes on six dimensions of implementation, coded from D3.1 and validated by all partners. Stage 3 compares outcomes on five dimensions, combining the Theories of Change (ToCs) with the evidence of D4.1 and of a workshop with all partners (7 October 2026). The comparison of the contexts (Stage 1) shows that the stability of the regime rests less on open opposition to the initiatives than on political inertia, administrative constraints, organisational fatigue and forms of participation that do not redistribute power, and that bridging actors are present in every case. The six cases fall into three distinct patterns of interaction between niche initiatives and established regimes. In Turin and Barcelona (embedded niches), initiatives led by organisations and by the third sector work with a regime that acts as a partner or incorporates them, through dense networks of intermediary actors; their main risk is co-optation. In Vienna and Órgiva (contested niches), citizen-led initiatives encounter resistance from established decision-making authorities, which limits the opportunities for collaboration. In Tartu and Espoo (invited participation), the participatory processes are primarily initiated and controlled by regime actors, while niche initiatives are either externally stimulated or have yet to emerge. The deliberation processes (Stage 2) took the form of researcher-facilitated stakeholder forums rather than mini-publics, and were not linked to formal decision-making processes. They largely reproduced the relations already in place: where the initiative was in conflict with the decision-holding regime, those regime actors did not take part. What mattered most was which part of the regime was present at the final joint panel, where niche and regime were meant to meet and where the role-playing game needed real counterparts. Five types of deliberative arena emerge from the comparison, each associated with a different scope of the Theory of Change. The outcomes (Stage 3) are still emerging and mostly cognitive and relational: a more systemic understanding of the problem, its reframing in terms of justice, and greater mutual recognition and trust among participants. Governance-related outcomes remain largely limited to proposals and to stronger cooperation between actors. Implementation has started only in Barcelona, where the initiative retains control over the proposed actions, which were designed with the involvement of regime actors. Compared with the historical examples studied in WP2, the case studies confirm therole of bridging actors, funding and legal frameworks, and show that the openness of the regime shapes the involvement of decision-making authorities in deliberation and varies across levels of government. For the policy recommendations developed under Task 4.3, the comparative analysis suggests adopting context-sensitive approaches instead of a one-size-fits-all model. Key considerations include involving from the start the level of government that holds the relevant decision, building on existing interfaces and coordination bodies, linking participation to the planning cycle, supporting the material conditions of participation of grassroots organisations and vulnerable groups, and planning follow-up and implementation from the outset.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Taffuri et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: