Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Biochar (BC) amendment is a means of increasing soil organic carbon (SOC) and has been explored frequently using high application rates in controlled experiments. Smaller rates and application under on-farm experimental conditions are less studied but considered more realistic. Here, we report results from field-scale BC application on five commercial arable farms in Switzerland with annual doses of 1 t BC/ha over 3–5 years. We analysed SOC and nitrogen changes and soil organic matter thermal stability using high-resolution volumetric soil sampling, including subsoil down to 60 cm for fields split into BC-treated and control. Our analysis revealed three main findings. First, unlike in controlled field experiments with high BC application, using low BC rates at the field level showed no uniform SOC stock increase, but differences were noted between farms, with some controls even outperforming the BC treatment. Second, for fields where SOC increased more than the amount of BC applied relative to the control field, thermal analysis revealed a relative increase not only in the high-temperature region of BC itself (> 450 °C) but also in the thermally more labile fraction below 350 °C. By contrast, the same labile thermal region declined for fields where SOC increased less than expected with BC addition. Finally, SOC accrual with BC required significantly less nitrogen than the same increase without BC, a finding that deserves further attention, as it suggests that SOC sequestration with BC is particularly nitrogen efficient.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Leifeld et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: