Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Purpose This study aims to develop and apply the Cybersecurity Communication Quality Index (CCQI) to assess the observable quality of public institutional cybersecurity warnings. It examines whether warnings provide the communication qualities needed for threat recognition, feasible action, temporal interpretation, credibility, preventive learning and post-exposure user support. Design/methodology/approach A deductive qualitative content analysis was conducted on 55 public cybersecurity risk messages issued between 2023 and 2025 by Croatian institutional and public-service sources. Each message was independently coded by two coders across six CCQI dimensions using a predefined three-point ordinal instrument. Intercoder reliability was assessed using exact agreement and weighted Cohen’s kappa before adjudication. The final data set was analysed descriptively by overall score, dimension, source family and year. Findings The corpus achieved a high mean CCQI score of 90.5 on a 0–100 scale. Threat recognition clarity and credibility were the strongest dimensions, showing that most messages made the threat recognisable and institutionally verifiable. User support orientation was the weakest relative dimension, indicating less consistent guidance on reporting, verification, assistance or recovery after possible exposure. The high scores require cautious interpretation because of possible ceiling effects, corpus selection and differences in the applicability of the scoring criteria across message types. Practical implications The CCQI offers institutions a transparent review tool for strengthening public cybersecurity warnings before or after publication. It can help communication and cybersecurity teams identify whether warnings provide concrete action steps, verification routes, preventive learning and post-exposure support, rather than merely naming a threat or issuing general caution. Social implications Clearer cybersecurity warnings can help citizens recognise online threats, take protective action and seek assistance after possible exposure. By identifying whether public warnings provide concrete action steps, verification routes and recovery guidance, the CCQI can support more user-oriented institutional communication. This is socially relevant because phishing, impersonation scams and digital fraud increasingly affect everyday users who must make quick decisions under uncertainty. Originality/value The study treats institutional cybersecurity warnings as evaluable communication artefacts and introduces a replicable message-level diagnostic index that distinguishes aggregate quality from dimension-specific strengths and weaknesses.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gombar et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: