Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Repetitive negative thinking (RNT) is widely regarded as a transdiagnostic process in youth internalizing problems, yet shared process characteristics do not necessarily imply a stable common measurement structure or uniform temporal relations with symptoms. We examined whether commonality across these evidential levels is mutually supportive using two independent open datasets. Study 1 reanalyzed item-level data from Dutch adolescents (N = 3,869), including brief and full Penn State Worry Questionnaire items and rumination/reflection items. Ordinal confirmatory factor analysis, exploratory structural equation modeling (ESEM), item response theory/differential item functioning diagnostics, and supplementary network analysis were used to evaluate the robustness of measurement conclusions. Study 2 used three-wave data from the RETHINK prevention trial (N = 365; ages 16–22 years). Free-lag random-intercept cross-lagged panel models examined bidirectional within-person relations between content-independent RNT and transdiagnostic internalizing symptoms, brooding and depression, and worry and anxiety, with adjustment for randomized condition, inverse-probability weighting, and an alternative anxiety measure for robustness checks. In Study 1, brief and full worry scores were highly correlated, but item-level structural conclusions differed. A content-specific three-factor model received relatively strong support, whereas the conventional bifactor model was unstable under the brief-item specification and failed to converge under the full 26-item specification. ESEM indicated substantive cross-loadings and structure related to reverse wording. In Study 2, no stable directional association emerged between content-independent RNT and transdiagnostic internalizing symptoms. Depression predicted later brooding more strongly in the later interval, although this evidence weakened after multiple-comparison correction. Worry–anxiety relations varied depending on whether anxiety was assessed with the GADQ-IV or GAD-7. Overall, shared measurement structure and within-person temporal functioning represent related but non-interchangeable levels of evidence. Commonality at one level should not be generalized to another without direct testing, and stronger theoretical claims about RNT require complete measurement, defensible model specification, and within-person temporal evidence.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
李世英 et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: