Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Three candidate materials are evaluated here for an automobile half-shaft: AISI 1025 carbon steel, a Kevlar 29 fabric composite, and an 11-layer radially graded steel/Al 2 O 3 functionally graded material (FGM). The reference geometry corresponds to a Mahindra KUV100 passenger car (shaft diameter 68 mm, length 442 mm, flange diameter 203 mm), with a per-half-shaft design torque of 951.89 N·m derived from the published engine and gearbox data. A closed-form theoretical framework is developed first, including exact radial integrals for the torsional rigidity, flexural rigidity, and inertia of the graded section, and is implemented in Python. The numerical study employs Ansys Mechanical APDL 2025 R2 with SOLID186 brick elements on a shared-topology bonded model, exercised through four solution branches: linear-static, modal, full harmonic response, and eigenvalue buckling, with a five-level mesh-independence study. Theory and simulation agree to within 1.4% on static deflection and 2.7% on fundamental frequency for all three shafts. Among the candidates, the graded shaft returns the smallest static deflection (0.0577 mm), the highest fundamental frequency (371.8 Hz), the highest critical torque (2215 kN·m), and the smallest resonant amplitude under torque excitation (1.16 mm), while weighing 26.2% less than steel (11.81 kg against 15.99 kg). The Kevlar shaft is the lightest at 2.93 kg, an 81.7% saving, yet its Tsai-Hill reserve factor under the shear-dominated load path is 3.7 with representative aramid ply strengths and approaches 1.1 for a low-fiber-fraction fabric laminate, and its resonant amplitude (6.15 mm) is the largest of the set. Elastic stability margins exceed 475 for every candidate, so first yield rather than buckling governs. Steel remains the default for conventional service, Kevlar suits mass-critical applications subject to strict laminate quality control, and the FGM offers the best combined stiffness, vibration, and stability performance per unit mass.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Saeed Asiri (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: