Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Hydroxyl-radical encounters with sulfur compounds can form short S···O contacts assigned as two-center three-electron (2c–3e) hemibonds. Here we test whether the descriptors commonly used to identify that encounter also specify the early time chemistry reported for the corresponding substrates. Dimethyl sulfide(CH3)2S, thiourea, CH4N2S, and thiocyanate, SCN–, were evaluated with the same electronic-structure protocol and descriptor definitions. All three encounters satisfy the same qualitative hemibond-assignment criteria ─ short S···O separation, shared spin, substantial Mayer bond order, partial fragment charge transfer and a QTAIM bond path ─ although their numerical descriptor values are not identical. The shared-spin/Mayer assignment is retained in a matched frozen-geometry comparison using PBE0, CAM-B3LYP, M06–2X and ωB97X-V. In contrast, the literature reports distinct early time signatures for the three aqueous systems: a directly observed S–O three-electron-bonded transient for dimethyl sulfide, radical-cation/hydroxide chemistry for thiourea, and an adduct/oxidation sequence for thiocyanate. Neutral S-methylisothiourea and thiophene provide computational boundary cases rather than additional experimental anchors. The comparison therefore identifies a limit of the encounter assignment: within this heterogeneous set, the same qualitative hemibond classification does not map uniquely onto the reported early time signature. The encounter descriptors characterize an electronic-structure motif; assigning a reaction mechanism requires evidence for the subsequent reaction coordinate and solvent-dependent state evolution.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Silva et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: