Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Purpose This study aims to examine the limits of formal procedural objectivity in the context of agentic artificial intelligence (AAI). Fairness and transparency, while procedurally necessary, are ethically inconsistent with AAI. The study advances the concept of inclusive objectivity and elucidate how AAI institutionalizes structural inequality and epistemic injustice in labour and socio-economic domains and propose an ethics of encounter vis-a-vis the ethics of execution so as to address the intrinsic tensions between AAI and inclusive objectivity. Design/methodology/approach The study adopts a philosophical and conceptual methodology combining theoretical analysis with real-life examples to demonstrate how procedural objectivity of AAI often conceals embedded biases and exclusions. The authors examine the assumptions of procedural objectivity in the context of AAI through a close philosophical engagement in labour markets and socio-economic domains. Findings The authors find that the presence of fairness and transparency alone is insufficient in realising and accessing objectivity, especially when decision-making authority is delegated to AAI. AAI, by displacing human judgement, aligns with exclusionary forms of objectivity and deepens structural inequality. The AAI systems embed exclusion, producing durable epistemic and social disadvantages across labour and economic domains. Hence, the authors introduce “inclusive objectivity” based on situated knowledge. Inclusive objectivity accommodates relational dependencies and contextual judgements, and therefore, precludes AAI from becoming too exclusionary. Inclusive objectivity is incompatible with AAI that functions autonomously. It is about recognizing moral asymmetries and reflecting on the lived experiences, the singularities of suffering and the structural inequalities. Social implications The authors argue that objectivity in AAI must be reconceptualized as a relational and inclusive construct, attentive to power, context and the plurality of lived experience. Only then can AAI ethics move beyond technical fixes to address the moral imperatives of justice, recognition and human agency. This study contends that inclusive objectivity stands in structural tension with AAI. Originality/value The authors explain how AAI neutrality and algorithmic bias work in the case of socio-economic contexts, particularly labour-related decisions, and propose a new alternative notion of “inclusive objectivity” and foreground it in the context of relational, lived and historically situated understanding of knowledge and how it impacts labour market and life outcomes. The authors postulate how inclusive objectivity contributes epistemologically and with respect to the newer notion of ethics of encounter, in contrast to the ethics of execution.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Misra et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: