Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Across much of the world, archaeological layers post-dating a valued ‘classical’ or ‘national’ antiquity, especially those of Islamic polities, have been removed, summarized, or left atop the section. This article examines a well-defined case: the late medieval and early modern horizon of western India’s Deccan, labelled the ‘Muslim-Maratha layer’ in excavation reports. Stratigraphies from Nevasa, Brahmapuri, and Nasik-Jorwe, notices in Indian Archaeology: A Review, and a Daulatabad case study show the fourteenth–eighteenth centuries registered atop every sequence but interpreted in almost none. Three reinforcing causes emerge: a disciplinary preference for prehistory; an institutional split between standing ‘monuments’ and excavated ‘sites’, encoded in the term ‘layer’; and a colonial Hindu–Muslim–British periodization that cast Muslim-ruled centuries as an interruption and still shapes heritage politics. The article proposes integrating excavation, building archaeology, remote sensing, and archaeology-of-Islam methods, arguing the case matters well beyond South Asia for how historical archaeologies treat the Islamic past.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Pushkar Sohoni (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: