Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A black hole-neutron star merger makes a kilonova only if the star is torn apart outside the innermost stable orbit; otherwise the hole swallows it whole and the merger is electromagnetically silent. Numerical relativity has mapped the boundary, and the Foucart fitting formula compresses that map into one algebraic expression in mass ratio, spin and compactness. This budget evaluates that formula across a nine-cell grid of mass ratio and spin, converts remnant mass to a dynamical-ejecta estimate with an adopted unbound fraction, and prints the zero cells at full size: for much of the grid the correct ejecta budget is exactly nothing. Headline values are bh unbound fraction of remnant bh25 = 0.35; bh q3 spin0 isco radius bh25 = 6; bh q3 spin0 remnant mass solar bh25 = 0; bh q3 spin0 dynamical ejecta solar bh25 = 0; bh q3 spin5 isco radius bh25 = 4.233; bh q3 spin5 remnant mass solar bh25 = 0.1014. The zero entries are results, not gaps: each one is a merger class for which telescope time would be spent chasing debris that was never ejected.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
William Alexander Aldred (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: