Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Cotton production in China, particularly in Xinjiang, faces phosphorus (P) fixation in calcareous soils and soil-P accumulation under excessive fertilization. We assessed relative yield attainment under nutrient-return-based P rates against trial-specific model-estimated plateaus using 331 P rate–yield observations from 35 articles (2002–2025; 67 independent trials). Each trial was fitted with a linear-plus-plateau model; pooled attainment was estimated by article-level cluster-robust meta-analysis. Pooled attainment was 97.99% (95% confidence interval [CI], 96.29–99.71%), below 100% (p = 0.024) but above the prespecified 95% non-inferiority threshold (p < 0.001); predicted yield averaged 94.88 kg·ha−1 below the mean plateau yield (1.73%). Subgroup tests found no significant differences in relative attainment across planting regions, periods, soil textures, Olsen-P classes, or the source of the whole-plant P-uptake coefficient (k); meta-regression found no significant associations with k, plateau yield, initial Olsen-P, or year. This concerns relative attainment, not effects on absolute-yield potential or P requirements. Sensitivity estimates were generally similar; non-inferiority was not confirmed in the strict model-fit subset (96.47%; 95% CI, 92.28–100.86%; p = 0.230) or at the 97.5% threshold (p = 0.281). We conclude that nutrient-return-based P recommendations, derived from the target yield and the coefficient k, serve as an initial benchmark, where these two input parameters require local calibration accounting for soil-P supply, residue return, and field conditions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Zhou et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: