Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The presence of missing records due to sensor failures in weather stations compromises data quality, environmental research, and machine learning applications. Evidence remains limited on how missingness conditions, target variables, covariates, and dataset characteristics jointly affect imputation performance. This study aimed to investigate how these factors influence imputation performance. A complete 30-year database (1996–2025) with daily data from Piracicaba, Brazil, was employed to construct a stochastic framework for evaluating linear interpolation (LI), daily average imputation (DAI), KNN, ARIMAX, and Random Forest imputation (RFI). Performance was assessed by averaging R2, RMSE, and KGE over 600 iterations. Subsequently, the techniques were applied to daily datasets from two locations in the United States for 2021–2025. Results from the stochastic framework showed that LI effectively filled one-day gaps in air temperature, whereas multivariate techniques performed better for consecutive gaps of five days or longer. For global radiation, multivariate methods provided the best estimates. Furthermore, the results revealed that RFI and KNN were less sensitive to increasing missingness conditions than the other techniques. The application to the two U.S. locations further showed that climatic and dataset characteristics affected method performance. Notably, LI efficiently filled all target variables under most evaluated missingness conditions at the location with marked interannual climatic stability. DAI exhibited unstable performance and was generally inferior to the remaining techniques. Collectively, these results can guide method selection for researchers requiring complete weather records and support future research toward more reliable and efficient imputation strategies.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rozinholli et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: