Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Automated landform classification methods enable the production of various representations of the Earth’s surface, although their effectiveness can vary significantly depending on the algorithm, spatial scale and morphological characteristics of the study area. Reliable landform classification is essential for sustainable spatial planning, as it makes it possible to systematically characterize the natural features of a territory, identify its morphological heterogeneity, and account for natural constraints in planning economic development and the use of natural resources. This study compares three automated terrain classification methods for the Mangystau Peninsula (western Kazakhstan): the Geomorphons method, the classification based on the Topographic Position Index (TPI) and Slope Position Classification. The aim was to evaluate the influence of spatial analysis parameters on classification results when mapping the main morphological features in arid plateau conditions. The analysis was carried out in ArcGIS Pro 3.6 using the ALOS AW3D30 digital surface model with a resolution of 1 arc-second (approximately 30 m), projected to a cell size of 27.08 m. Geomorphons was applied with three parameter scenarios (search distance/skip distance/flatness threshold of 450 m/60 m/1.5°, 1500 m/120 m/2° and 3000 m/300 m/3°), and the TPI-based classification and Slope Position Classification with three neighborhood sizes. The resulting classes were assigned to four morphological groups: positive forms, sloped surfaces, flat surfaces and negative forms. Agreement between the methods was assessed with overall agreement, Cohen’s kappa and quantity and allocation disagreement. The accuracy of the nine classifications was assessed against 800 reference points selected by stratified random sampling and labelled by interpreters without access to the classifications. Overall accuracy ranged from 20.6% to 83.8%; flat surfaces were classified with an F1 score (the harmonic mean of user’s and producer’s accuracy) of 0.80–0.93 in seven of the nine classifications, whereas sloped surfaces and positive and negative forms reached F1 ≤ 0.36. The results show that there is no universal method suitable for all landform classification tasks. The findings highlight the importance of considering class-specific accuracy, the spatial scale and the prevalence of flat surfaces when selecting a classification approach. The comparative evaluation has practical implications for the preparation of reliable geomorphological information used in regional spatial planning and natural resource management. The classification results can be used in the preparation of geomorphological maps, the identification of natural constraints on land use, the preliminary assessment of the spatial vulnerability of landscapes, and the planning of tourism activities, taking into account the specifics of the relief and the need to preserve the natural heritage. Thus, digital geomorphometry can serve as an important source of geospatial information for sustainable regional development. Nevertheless, the interpretation of the origin of landform features and specific geological processes, as well as the assessment of environmental sustainability, require further investigation based on geological data, environmental studies and field observations.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bektursynova et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: