Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Purpose The aim of this study is to explore the corporate strategic meaning of being included in the Islamic index for the firms in the Borsa Istanbul Participation Index. Within the framework of legitimacy theory, the study investigates whether firms perceive inclusion in the index as a strategic choice or merely as a means of symbolic legitimacy. Design/methodology/approach A qualitative research design was adopted in this study, employing semi-structured interviews as the data collection tool. Interviews were conducted with investor relations officials from 82 firms listed in the Borsa Istanbul Participation Index. Findings The content analysis reveals that 73% of the firms do not consider inclusion in the Islamic index as a strategic goal; instead, they experience coincidental (unintentional) legitimacy because their current financial structures passively align with the requirements. 11% of the firms exhibit symbolic compliance, assigning reputational importance to the index while remaining flexible depending on conventional market conditions. The remaining 16% demonstrate substantive commitment, adopting compliance with the participation principles as a core corporate mandate and shaping their financial strategies accordingly. The findings suggest that the vast majority of corporations view indexation primarily as a symbolic form of legitimacy. Research limitations/implications The findings of this study provide critical, actionable implications for various market stakeholders. Shariah advisory boards, regulatory authorities and policymakers may utilize these insights when structuring regulatory oversight, modifying index eligibility criteria or designing behavioral compliance indicators. Furthermore, the results offer investor relations departments a strategic framework to better navigate corporate communications and manage expectations of Shariah-conscious market actors. Practical implications Some firms view inclusion in the participation index primarily as an external legitimization tool, without fully adhering to the principles of Islamic finance in practice. This finding contributes to legitimacy theory by providing empirical evidence of strategic decoupling in corporate finance. Such discrepancies pose a significant risk to the reliability and credibility of the index, showing that symbolic legitimacy can easily undermine the structural goals of ethical market participation. Social implications Although there is a general consensus that the participation index criteria should be tightened, it is anticipated that the vast majority of firms will struggle to adapt to these changes given their existing financial infrastructure. At this juncture, it is crucial for Islamic financial institutions to expand their product diversity and build the institutional capacity necessary to meet the financing needs of large-scale firms. Otherwise, tightening the index criteria may result in many firms dropping out of the system, potentially undermining the stability and confidence of Shariah-conscious investors. Originality/value Previous studies on Islamic indices have primarily focused on their financial performance and asset pricing. However, the existing literature has largely overlooked the strategic decisions of firms regarding inclusion in Islamic indices, their motivations for doing so and their perspectives on Shariah-conscious investors.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ülev et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: