Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Purpose The purpose of this study is to examine how firms use different responses to consumer-to-consumer incivility on social media during service recovery. The authors use attribution theory and service climate to examine outcomes of observer perceptions of two response styles, justifying versus denouncing incivility. A key mediator (observers’ perceived effort) and moderator (observers’ consumer-to-consumer justice) are tested. Design/methodology/approach Study 1’s online content analysis illustrates the phenomenon. Study 2 (incivility from a troll) and Study 3 (incivility from a loyal customer) use service failure and complaint scenarios to assess complementary mediation of observers’ perceived effort and service climate. Findings Study 1 finds that firms justify incivility more than denounce it in practice. Studies 2 and 3 reveal that denouncing incivility leads to greater observer purchase and engagement intentions through increased effort perceptions but only if observers perceive incivility as an injustice. Effort’s mediation is robust to controlling another mediator, perceived service climate. Research limitations/implications The authors extend attribution theory with a distinct action and stakeholder conceptually different from a firm’s effort to handle a complainant’s failure. Effort perceptions attributed to a firm are based on an action of handling a nonconsumption failure of consumer-to-consumer incivility (rather than an action of correcting a product or service consumption failure), and this is perceived by observer stakeholders who did not suffer a failure (rather than a complainant stakeholder). Practical implications Firms are eight times more likely to justify incivility than denounce it. However, denouncing unjust incivility from trolls or loyal customers can increase engagement and purchase intentions. Originality/value To the best of the authors’ knowledge, this is the first inquiry into observers’ attribution of perceived effort of a firm when it handles consumer-to-consumer uncivil interactions on a digital service channel.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bacile et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: