Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A material misstatement that escapes detection during an audit does not, by itself, establish an auditor's legal failure. The problem is that Indonesian public accountant law has yet to provide a clear threshold for determining when inherent audit limitations become attributable professional failure. This study aims to analyze the legal function of reasonable assurance in distinguishing between these two conditions and to establish a normative basis for attributing auditor liability. The study uses a doctrinal legal method supported by qualitative empirical data, analyzing Law No. 5 of 2011, its implementing regulations, OJK regulations, the Indonesian Public Accountants Professional Standards, and interviews with 13 informants: 10 audit-service users and three Public Accountants. The findings show that reasonable assurance already operates across professional standards, legal protection, supervision, sanctions, and quality management, although its attribution function remains fragmented and has yet to be formulated as a coherent legal standard. The empirical findings further reveal that some users understand that an audit does not provide absolute assurance, while expectations that auditors should detect errors and fraud remain broader than an audit's professional limits. This study constructs reasonable assurance as a normative liability threshold, namely a pre-liability attribution test for assessing professional departures that are material, traceable, and substantively connected to the basis of the audit opinion. This concept integrates professional standards, audit quality, and legal attribution within a single framework that strengthens auditor accountability without turning an audit into a guarantee of absolute accuracy. Academically, this study contributes to the development of Indonesian professional liability law by bridging auditing standards and legal attribution through an integrated normative framework. It advances the concept of reasonable assurance beyond its conventional function as an auditing standard by positioning it as a legal criterion for distinguishing unavoidable audit risk from professionally attributable negligence.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bahari et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: