Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Here we take experience as fundamental, with its structure corresponding to realized mathematical organization. We hypothesize that systems share an experiential feature exactly when they realize the organization constituting it in corresponding states or histories. An emulator therefore has experiential features; the question is which it shares with a biological brain. We compare them through coarse-grainings: reduced descriptions whose dynamics are exactly or approximately self-contained. But which organization and dynamics must be preserved? We conjecture that, at a suitable system boundary, human brain dynamics admit a coherent, scientifically accessible coarse-graining retaining the organization necessary and sufficient for targeted experiential features. The algorithmic agent provides a candidate architecture: world- and self-models with internal reporting, valuation, and planning. For deterministic systems, the content and experimental protocols determine the coarsest closed coarse-graining retaining that content, unique apart from state labels. Systems agreeing on that content under every protocol sequence have coarsest coarse-grainings with matching reachable states and transitions, up to relabeling. We show that, for an exact tracker whose only operations are world symmetries and observations that overwrite its record, every sequence acts as a reversible symmetry or an irreversible overwrite. These retained updates form a monoid with a symmetry group core, in both digital systems and differential equation models with resets. First-person observations, neural measurements, and report analysis under matched protocols can identify and test candidate coarse-grainings of human brain dynamics and their update monoids. Under our preservation hypothesis, a validated candidate specifies what emulation must preserve. We discuss neuronal, whole-brain, language, and multimodal emulators, and extensions to other species and artificial systems.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Giulio Ruffini (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: