Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Wicked problems (WPs) involve multiple stakeholders with conflicting incentives and fragmented knowledge, while attempts to solve one part of a problem create new problems elsewhere. Global urban rodent infestations are the epitome of generational WPs, remaining deeply rooted for centuries. Rising demand for rodent control across 195 countries, along with insurance claims and public complaint data, suggests worsening trends. Rodents contribute to an estimated 400 million rodent-related zoonoses per annum. Additionally, they contaminate foods and cause building fires, disabled vehicles, and structural damage. Annual costs may reach US$40–60 billion and could escalate with climate change and urbanization. Building off examples from mosquito and wastewater surveillance, as well as the few promising rat-control programs, we construct a model for addressing this issue. WPs are resolved by identifying stakeholders and acknowledging their incentive:risk profiles. We name the four most common stakeholders: property owners, pest management professionals (PMPs), researchers and public health agencies, then map their profiles and identify how they impede one another’s progress. For instance, PMPs possess detailed knowledge of local infestations but have little incentive to share proprietary data or access to potential research sites. In a collaborative relationship, they could provide site access to researchers while being incentivized by client heat maps and science-validated control tools. This can facilitate cross-platform data sharing. Researchers could then better support public health agencies with ecological and pathogen data, helping shift responses from enforcement toward education and prevention. Property owners benefit from reduced risks of stigma, fines, illness, and property damage. Sometimes the best science is not a new technology or tool, but recognition of stakeholder interests and a commitment to exchanges that benefit each group without increasing its risks. Breaking knowledge silos and aligning incentives may allow even the most entrenched urban rodent problems to be addressed. Our framework shows that effective One Health approaches to urban rodent infestations depend on aligning stakeholder incentive: risk profiles.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Parsons et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: