Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Groundwater overdraft and climate change are driving large-scale agricultural land retirement across the world’s water-stressed farming regions, but the hydrologic, ecological, and economic outcomes of retirement depend heavily on where it occurs. Using the San Joaquin Valley, California, as a case study, we identify least-cost spatial configurations of cropland retirement that simultaneously meet groundwater and species habitat goals. We constructed species distribution models, estimated field-level applied water and foregone agricultural revenue, and used mixed-integer linear programming (prioritizr) to solve water-only, habitat-only, and combined (water + habitat) retirement optimizations for present and future scenarios, solving the water-only framework at both regional and individual groundwater basin scales. Our results show that meeting regional overdraft reduction targets required retiring roughly 326,000 ha of cropland at approximately $1.44B in foregone revenue under baseline conditions, rising to about 367,000 ha ($1.60B) under a high-emissions scenario. Regional planning met targets at approximately 4.6% less area and 18.5% lower cost than basin-by-basin planning, revealing a trade-off between regional efficiency and local feasibility in achieving long-term groundwater sustainability. The land needed to meet overdraft reduction goals contained far more suitable habitat than the conservation targets required (170–1298% of each target), indicating significant potential for habitat co-benefits when water-driven retirement was spatially coordinated. Our results do not suggest the retirement configurations as a prescriptive design, but rather as a demonstration of a generalizable spatial planning framework for identifying portfolios that balance irrigation reductions with conservation co-benefits and economic efficiency under climate uncertainty.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Pepperdine et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: