Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Time-dependent atom-pair correlations provide a direct connection between microscopic vibrational dynamics and momentum- and energy-resolved scattering spectra. In crystalline materials, however, practical multiphonon calculations commonly retain interatomic correlations at one phonon while reducing higher orders to atomic self-correlations. We formulate a deterministic correlation-function method that evaluates coherent inelastic scattering at specified phonon order and in the all-order harmonic sum. Expanding the Gaussian atom-pair intermediate scattering function generates finite orders, whereas retaining its exponential gives the all-order result, avoiding explicit enumeration of n-phonon mode tuples. We apply the method to powder-averaged graphite and diamond at 300 and 1200 K in a fixed-lattice harmonic model and isolate the signed distinct contribution by subtracting the same-atom self-term from the full atom-pair spectrum. The distinct multiphonon signal is substantially larger in graphite than in diamond and develops pronounced positive and negative structures whose net integral is strongly reduced by cancellation. Two-phonon scattering is dominant, but structured third- and fourth-order contributions remain; a smaller fifth-and-higher-order residual is clearest for graphite at 1200 K. Pair-distance analysis at 1200 K finds comparable near-neighbor-group weights relative to self-scattering, but a larger contribution from more distant pairs in graphite. Larger normalized displacement correlations, particularly for interlayer out-of-plane motion, provide a dynamical context for this contrast. Explicit higher orders and finer phonon meshes preserve the material contrast and order hierarchy while revealing residual amplitude sensitivity. These results provide a material- and observable-specific assessment of the self-approximation within the harmonic model.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Shinsuke Nakayama (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: