Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Quantum tunneling has no shortage of clocks. What has been missing is a criterion for deciding when different clock records measure one physical time. We formulate each clock as a calibrated quantum instrument and prove a necessary-and-sufficient common-time factorization theorem: a common event-conditioned time exists exactly when the declared record measures lie in the compact convex image of preparation-independent calibration kernels. For finite records this is a convex feasibility problem, and its total-variation residual is a linear program. The theorem separates agreement of means from existence of a common time law. Finite wave-packet Larmor and Ramsey histories locate the first reduction boundary. Their weak phase records admit an accurate common scalar description, whereas complete \(x,y,z\) records retain branch-dependent backaction outside that scalar. The attoclock analysis locates a second boundary: exit-local temporal information, exit momentum, continuum Coulomb evolution, and the distant detector angle belong to different segments of the same prepared history. Local and asymptotic records are not interchangeable without a propagation map. In one rubidium-87-scale Gaussian-barrier model we combine a localized Larmor clock with a downstream momentum detector and reproduce the spin-momentum joint law by independent spectral and split-operator calculations. A decisive counterexample yields two momentum mixtures with transmitted clock states equal below \(10⁻¹⁴\) in trace distance but downstream detector laws separated by \(0.210857\) in total variation. Any predictor based only on the local clock state must therefore err by at least \(0.105429\) on one preparation; the momentum-paired history restores predictive sufficiency. These results establish a strict hierarchy: scalar phase, complete local clock state, and momentum-paired history are successively stronger predictive descriptions. A tunneling time is a genuine physical reduction only where the declared record family factorizes through one retained temporal variable. The clocks do not compete for one primitive number; each is a calibrated functional of the complete prepared quantum history.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Dohyeong Lee (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: