Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
We propose an interdisciplinary approach, integrating discursive, rhetorical, and historical elements into the selected corpus. We rely on the concept of ethos developed by Aristotle and later adopted by Maingueneau and Amossy, as well as the concept of pathos, adopted by Charaudeau and Plantin. We also use some key tools of the French discursive analysis, through a qualitative analysis and an internal and external critique of the sources, as well as a content analysis. Furthermore, we employ the notion of emotional communities proposed by the historian Rosenwein. These concepts help us interpret the represented identities, the role of the interlocutors, and the procedures implemented in the trial against Flaubert. We see that the lawyers – Me Sénard and Me Pinard – resort to the emotional communities to which they belong and to discourses associated with the beliefs upheld by the doxa of their time-space. The prosecution argues that the novel encourages adultery and misleads young readers. The defence argues that the novel is an edifying and exemplary tale about an unhappy woman seeking an escape from her monotonous life. The discursive modus operandi of the two lawyers in the use of emotions, as well as their movements between emotional communities, is uncovered. This analysis of the trial against Flaubert ultimately aims to better understand the French bourgeois society of the 19th century, its ways of thinking and feeling, and its moral, ethical, and aesthetic limits.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Renata Aiala de Mello (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: