Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background and Objectives: The five-way anthropometric fractionation method partitions body mass into adipose, muscle, bone, residual and skin tissue. Closure of the five masses on scale mass is testable without a reference method but is necessary, not sufficient, for validity. We quantified the closure error by sex, discipline and morphology. Methods: 1488 elite Cuban athletes (975 men, 513 women) from 33 disciplines were profiled under ISAK protocol. The five masses were computed from raw anthropometry with the published equations. Confidence intervals accounted for clustering by discipline. Results: The bias was −1.42 kg in men (95% CI −2.34 to −0.50) and −3.58 kg in women (−4.44 to −2.66), with limits of agreement of −7.85 to +5.02 and −9.33 to +2.18 kg. No proportional component was detectable once clustering by discipline was taken into account, and in men a small component explained under 5% of the variance. In a mixed model of the error in kilograms with body mass as a covariate, discipline accounted for 33% and 38% of its variance. Underestimation was largest in tall, linear athletes, reaching −7.45 kg in female basketball. Conclusions: The method suits group description in men, systematically underestimates women, and agreement with total mass does not validate the tissue partition.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Veitía et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: