Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Predicting complex boundary value problems (BVPs), such as those involving seismic soil liquefaction, remains a fundamental challenge in geotechnical engineering. When numerical simulations deviate from observations, it is often difficult to distinguish whether discrepancies originate from intrinsic constitutive model limitations, calibration-induced trade-offs, or simplified hydro-mechanical assumptions. To investigate these issues, this study presents a comparative evaluation framework utilizing BVP-based inverse analysis and the hypoplastic model with intergranular strain (HP + IS) as a representative constitutive formulation. Supported by a comprehensive experimental database for Fujian sand, three element test-based calibration benchmarks are compared with mechanical and joint hydro-mechanical BVP optimizations. The results show that the calibration benchmarks leave noticeable discrepancies in BVP predictions, whereas the BVP-optimized parameter sets reproduce the main characteristics of pore-pressure and acceleration responses in the target and validation BVPs. Joint mechanical-hydraulic adjustment substantially improves settlement prediction in the target BVP, although the identified conductivity shows limited transferability. Element-level re-evaluation further reveals varying level of agreement: the principal cyclic contractancy in shearing tests are well captured, whereas other characteristics, such as oedometric compressibility and small-strain stiffness, show larger discrepancies. These observations provide a clearer understanding of HP + IS capabilities and limitations at the element and BVP levels under the investigated conditions. More importantly, they demonstrate the value of the proposed framework, which integrates inverse analysis, independent validation and element-level re-evaluation, in exploring possible sources of BVP prediction discrepancies, assessing constitutive capabilities, and informing calibration.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Deng et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: