Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Traditional cast-in-place concrete retaining systems for deep foundation pits generate substantial embodied carbon over their life cycle. Existing comparative studies often decouple mechanical safety verification from carbon emission accounting, lacking multi-dimensional uncertainty evaluation under equivalent deformation constraints. Using a deep foundation pit project in China, this study employs finite element analysis to compare the deformation and mechanical performance of two retaining schemes under identical geometry, soil-water parameters, and excavation conditions. Based on the emission factor method, life-cycle carbon emissions are quantified across four stages: material production, material transportation, on-site construction, and demolition-and-disposal. A total of 5,000 Monte Carlo simulations are performed under normal and uniform distributions, incorporating key parameters such as carbon emission factors, transport distances, steel component reuse cycles, and material loss rates. Results show that both schemes provide comparable deformation control and meet the Grade-I deformation criteria. At baseline, the all-steel retaining system emits 1094.526 tCO2e, only 37.11% of the concrete system's 2949.692 tCO2e, achieving a 62.89% carbon reduction. Sensitivity analysis indicates a break-even reuse number of approximately 3.7 for steel components; the all-steel system becomes more carbon-efficient when reuse reaches 4 or more. It retains its low-carbon advantage even under conservative high material loss scenarios or varied transportation distances and modes. Further Monte Carlo results show that the median life-cycle emission of the concrete system is about 2.2 times that of the all-steel system under the normal-distribution assumption and 2.7 times under the uniform-distribution assumption, and the interquartile ranges barely overlap for both distribution cases, demonstrating statistical robustness. This study confirms that the recyclable all-steel retaining system offers stable emission reduction benefits, providing theoretical and data support for low-carbon scheme selection and quantitative carbon assessment in deep excavations.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Huang et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: