Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Improving water quality is an outcome of many conservation efforts. However, setting goals for water quality improvement can be challenging due to the various uses and views of what constitutes good water quality. Previous studies have examined water quality perceptions, but there is little work on how differing framings may influence environmental outcomes. To address this gap, we examined the organizations affiliated with the 43 Areas of Concern (AOC) in the United States-Canada Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement. AOCs are locations with significant water quality degradation that have been prioritized for cleanup, where they move to delisted status once environmental conditions have been restored. The objective of this research is understanding how water quality is framed throughout, how water quality framings differ between the US and Canada, and how different framings of water quality relate to an AOC’s status of being delisted. We conduct a content analysis of documents from government and partner organizations in each of the AOCs in the US and Canada, and we categorize how the term water quality is framed into four categories: Biological, Chemical-Physical, Cultural-Spiritual, and Social-Recreational. We then quantitatively analyze the number of codes in each category using Wilcoxon rank-sum tests for non-parametric data and qualitatively analyze the coded segments using thematic analysis. Our quantitative results highlight limited differences in the framings between the US and Canada and no differences between listed and delisted AOCs. However, our qualitative results demonstrate nuances in Cultural-Spiritual and Social-Recreational framings of water quality, including the themes of how Cultural-Spiritual codes are framed in the two countries, highlighting a greater focus on Indigenous connection and economic outcomes. Understanding water quality framings is important to develop shared understandings of how water quality is defined and to set a foundation for policy and action for successful restoration in the Great Lakes.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jones-Crank et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: