Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The early twenty-first century has witnessed a resurgence of colonial dreams of frontier living, now at sea. Efforts to inhabit the ocean as a means to create new societies, known as ‘seasteading’, unabashedly draw on the rhetoric of nineteenth-century U.S. settler colonialism to frame contemporary forms of techno-capitalism and libertarianism. Driven by grandiose fantasies to open radically new political possibilities by enabling mobile, choice-based marine societies, seasteaders proudly frame their endeavours as utopian. In practice, however, recent attempts to found seasteads have drawn ire from locals and litigation from governments of nearby nations. Just as the U.S. West was not an uninhabited blank slate for pioneering, so the ocean is already home to a host of more-than-human beings and already divvied up into complicated zones subject to various forms of national and international governance. Contending with these realities has forced seasteaders to reframe their promise of new forms of sovereignty to a more modest proposal of sleek offshore living under flags of convenience, subject to international law and its regulations of time and space. This essay takes up the promise of oceanic utopianism to ask how particular infrastructures’ embodiments of history, religion, and politics enable and constrain the possibilities for reinventing society. I argue that the durability of religion in terrestrial infrastructures refuses seasteading’s promises to escape the constraints of history by taking to the waves. The measurement of longitude, establishment of the prime meridian, and institution of the Common Era – that is, the fundamental infrastructures of modern time and space – came into being through Christianity’s entanglement with geopolitics. Seasteaders’ adoption of modern infrastructures for marine living and their religious discourses of the settler frontier illuminate the recalcitrance of religion in the techniques by which they attempt to territorialize the ocean and foreclose the possibility of utopia.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jenna Supp‐Montgomerie (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: