Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Ancient soils record the air they weathered under: in carbon-dioxide-rich air, iron in a weathering profile forms siderite, and its absence in key late Archean palaeosols caps how much carbon dioxide was present. A concentration ceiling converts directly into a maximum logarithmic forcing, which can be subtracted from the required forcing to expose any shortfall in plain watts. Headline values are pal required forcing planck w m2 pal = 39.7; pal forcing at ceiling x10 w m2 pal = 12.32; pal shortfall feedback at x10 w m2 pal = 3.081; pal ceiling ppm x10 pal = 2800; pal forcing at ceiling x50 w m2 pal = 20.93; pal shortfall feedback at x50 w m2 pal = -5.529. At feedback-assisted response, even the strictest published ceiling supplies about four fifths of the requirement and mid-range ceilings exceed it; under Planck-only response the sufficient abundance rises near seventeen hundred times preindustrial, beyond every published ceiling, so the confrontation's verdict depends on climate response as much as on soil chemistry.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
William Alexander Aldred (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: