Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The limited-transpiration phenotype, a plateau in transpiration above a threshold vapour pressure deficit (VPD), is invoked to explain why grain sorghum conserves soil water better than maize. Most evidence comes from controlled environments, where VPD is imposed, and radiation is held constant. We treat a two-season field dataset as a methodological case study and ask whether such a threshold is identifiable from stem heat balance records. We analysed sap-flow records from 37 plants (18 in 2024, 19 in 2025) of one sorghum hybrid (rainfed) and one maize hybrid (rainfed and irrigated). The records cover a dry and a wet postflowering season in the Pannonian Basin, Hungary. Management differed between seasons, so inference is restricted to contrasts within seasons. Midday flux (09:00 to 17:00) from measured records only was normalised within plant and season and modelled against daily maximum VPD, adjusted for window day and clearness index. No breakpoint was identifiable at day level in five of the six combinations of group and season; the sixth (corrected p = 0.03) sat at the edge of the search grid and did not recur with other integration windows. Bootstrap intervals for the breakpoint covered up to 57% of the sampled range, and a simulation recovered a full plateau in 12%–48% of replicates. The data neither locate a threshold nor exclude one. The adjusted demand slope was positive in every group (0.051 to 0.119 kPa −1 ), lower in rainfed than in irrigated maize in both seasons, and not lower in rainfed sorghum. Reconstructed records changed no slope by more than 0.003 kPa −1 , but the 24-h total gave rainfed slopes near zero, so the integration window is itself an analytical choice. On that total, the interannual amplitude of sorghum flux per plant was 0.1% or 9.3% depending on window alignment, and 33% per unit ground area, so no crop ranking is supported. Density-scaled sorghum flux exceeded reference evapotranspiration and tabulated basal crop coefficients. The instrumented stems were most likely a size-biased subset of a dense stand. We set out the reporting items a field sap-flow record needs before a VPD threshold can be interpreted.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Pásztor et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: