Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Purpose In this paper, we explore the cultural production of the “dream candidate” from the perspective of HR workers, to elicit potential for future diversity and inclusion work. Design/methodology/approach We carried out semi-structured interviews with 17 HR officers in Norway, essential mediators between employers and candidates. We asked informants to define the “dream candidate” and analyzed how they made sense of the concept, and relatedly, how they constructed their expertise and role and navigated expectations, concerns and ideals in the hiring process. Findings Instead of listing ideal traits, our informants critiqued the dream candidate concept, framing it as a set of unreasonably ambitious requirements imposed by managers, including qualifications, experience and “culture fit”. While informants constructed their own role as the legal experts in the hiring process, they never mentioned the identity categories central to the law and to most theories of how inequality operates in organizations (such as gender or race). Rather, they critically highlighted managers' tendency to prioritize candidates who resemble either themselves or current employees and acknowledged that they also shared this tendency. Originality/value The study explores the “dream candidate” construct as a culturally produced and contested concept. The analysis shows that HR professionals navigate organizational desires for “sameness” (homosocial reproduction) by silencing societal demands for diversity (legal framework). It shows how HR professionals in a Scandinavian context describe their role in hiring and in producing inequality, and highlights the limits of focusing solely on legally protected identity categories to understand and address it.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Wang et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: