Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background Dental caries is traditionally understood as a biofilm-mediated disease driven by carbohydrate fermentation, acid production, and subsequent mineral dissolution. While this acidogenic paradigm remains fundamental, it does not fully account for differences in lesion initiation, localization, progression, arrest, or host tissue responses. This review aimed to critically integrate current evidence on microbial ecology, acidogenic mechanisms, salivary and mineral regulation, pulp–dentin interactions, and emerging neurobiological pathways to propose an updated host–biofilm–tooth model of caries pathogenesis. Methods A structured critical integrative review was performed using a framework-guided thematic synthesis approach. PubMed/MEDLINE, Scopus, Web of Science Core Collection, and Embase were systematically searched, complemented by citation tracking. Records were independently screened by two reviewers, and eligible studies were evaluated according to their mechanistic contribution and evidence directness. Findings were categorized as outcome-proximal evidence, mechanistically supportive evidence, or hypothesis-generating evidence. Results A total of 8,851 records were identified, with 5,356 unique records remaining after duplicate removal. Fifty core studies were included, comprising 35 database-derived studies and 15 studies identified through citation tracking. Evidence was synthesized into six interconnected domains: acidogenic and Streptococcus mutans -associated mechanisms, ecological biofilm dysbiosis, salivary and alkaligenic regulation, mineral homeostasis and lesion dynamics, pulp–dentin biological responses, and cholinergic/neurochemical signaling. Acid production remained the primary driver of demineralization; however, the synthesized evidence indicates that lesion behavior is modulated by microbial community structure, host-derived protective mechanisms, mineral availability, and tissue responsiveness. Cholinergic signaling represented a biologically plausible but currently unconfirmed regulatory pathway. Conclusion Dental caries should be viewed as a dynamic host–biofilm–tooth interaction rather than a solely acid-driven destructive process. The proposed framework integrates established acidogenic and ecological concepts with host regulatory mechanisms, providing a broader biological perspective and identifying new directions for mechanistic research and preventive strategies in oral health.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hamzayev et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: