Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
We settle the finite-model status of four single equational laws of order five, numbered 21714, 21864, 21865 and 21866 in the Equational Theories Project, together with their four duals (24200, 24199, 24197 and 24201). Every finite magma satisfying any of these laws has at most one element. For Equation 21866, the argument turns a left inverse of a canonical map on ordered pairs into a two-sided inverse by finiteness; a rigidity lemma for directed paths then forces all elements to coincide. Equation 21714 reduces to Equation 21866 by four explicit algebraic identities. Equations 21864 and 21865 yield the right-projection identity by finite equational derivations, supplied in full as Lean certificates. All eight statements have been checked against the Equational Theories Project's Lean library with its pinned Lean 4.29.1 toolchain (commit 8b87204d5b201e1cf6c69b8dcabb0558109bee00). The proofs do not rule out nontrivial infinite models, and hence do not establish that any of these laws is an Austin law. The supplementary archive ("Order5_Finite_Lean_Certificates_ElKhatibi.zip") contains the Lean 4 proof modules, the verification script ("VERIFY_ETP.sh"), and a SHA-256 manifest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Walid EL KHATIBI EL HANANA (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: