Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Microbially induced carbonate precipitation (MICP) and enzyme-induced carbonate precipitation (EICP) have been extensively investigated as alternatives to conventional soil stabilization methods. However, comparing reported results remains challenging because differences in soil fabric, reagent chemistry, treatment delivery, curing conditions, testing methods, and environmental exposure can influence the measured response. This critical review brings together the engineering evidence on strength and stiffness, hydraulic behavior, cyclic response, durability, field implementation, by-product management, and sustainability within one geotechnical verification framework. A literature-coverage search was conducted in Scopus and Web of Science Core Collection on 05 May 2026 and updated on 02 August 2026; the search was extended through 02 October 2026 to capture recent studies on field implementation, durability, ammonium management, and matched MICP-EICP comparisons. The review separates the maturity of the evidence (laboratory, physical model, meter scale or pilot, and field) from the magnitude of the reported effect. Total CaCO 3 content helps track treatment progress, but it cannot serve as a design variable on its own: surface-percolation MICP produced surface strengths of about 4.8–11.4 MPa at 5.6–33.2% CaCO 3 , whereas a field slope treatment produced a 0.14–1.02 MPa crust at 0.56–3.7% CaCO 3 , and precipitate location and morphology changed strength at similar content. The few protocol-matched studies suggest that EICP can give higher initial strength in silt and fine sand but lower retained strength after wet–dry and freeze–thaw cycling; these trends are still emerging and should not yet be used as selection criteria. Durability is still the main unresolved issue, and the various durability indicators cannot be pooled. Rinsing has removed about 95% of total ammonium at column and meter scale, but field evidence is still limited. Treatments should be accepted against project-specific mechanical, hydraulic, durability, uniformity, environmental, and field-verification requirements.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Saeed Alzahrani (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: